On the New York Daily News' website they had a poll asking whose fault it was that Mets' season has spiraled out of control. They gave you four options:
- The Wilpons have steered the team into the iceberg.
- Omar Minaya's personnel moves have been dreadful.
- Jerry Manuel's in-game decisions make him seem clueless.
- The players that haven't been able to win.
So they are telling us we can only pick one?
The biggest problem for the Mets is that it isn't one thing. There is no quick fix for the Mets. They need a complete overhaul.
First off, the Wilpon's are in no position to be running a major league ball team. Their finical and legal problems are holding the team back from completing deals that they need to do. It's hard to judge whether it's Minaya's fault, or the front office. He can't make a deal without first getting the approval by the owners. So who knows what happens behind closed doors. I don't think the Wilpon's will sell the team, but they could hand ownership responsibilities to a different person until they are able to collect themselves.
Minaya gets the brunt of the ridicule because he is the one who assembled this team. Like any GM, he has made some bad moves. Difference is in New York they are under the microscope more and usually for a lot more money than other teams, i.e. Oliver Perez. I'm actually not even that mad at Minaya. He did make some good moves in the offseason. R.A. Dickey, Hisanori Takahashi, Rod Barajas, and he still deserves credit for trading for Johan Santana and Angel Pagan back in 2008. Though he is not the teams biggest problem, I think it's just time to move in a different direction and let him go at the end of the year.
The Mets have a ton of talent on this team, but they can't take what is on paper to on the field. To me, that shows that the problem is with the coaching staff. I'm not one for blaming managers for the teams problems, but in this case I will. There has to be something that Manuel is doing wrong. Of course none of us know because we are not there in the Mets clubhouse playing with them, but you get the feeling something isn't right. Manuel, as well as Howard Johnson, need to be gone in 2011. The only coach I would keep is Dan Warthen because the Mets pitching has been outstanding this year.
Now onto the guys who actually make it happen on the field. It's been painful to watch the Mets offense go up to the plate and back to the dugout like clockwork. We've been watching games that are routinely 1-0 in the seventh inning, with no sign of life in the batting order. You can do whatever you want with the front office and coaching staff, but when it comes down to it the players need to perform, and they aren't doing that. It may just be time for a complete overhaul of this team, keeping only the cornerstones of the franchise.
So what to do in 2011? Well first off if the ownership wants to show anything to the fans of this team, they need to fire Minaya, Manuel, and all other coaches not named Dan Warthen. The replacement manager comes down to the three people; Joe Torre, Bobby Valentine, and Wally Backman. I'm a big fan of Backman, but the other two have much more experience than him, which would be important for this team. However, Torre will always be a Yankee to me, and I feel like Bobby V had his time here and they shouldn't go back to him. So I would go with Backman as the Mets manager in 2011.
Next comes down to the players. Big contracts like Carlos Beltran, Oliver Perez, Luis Castillo, and Francisco Rodriguez will try to be moved in the offseason. Beltran will have the most value, but like Perez and Castillo, if they were to move him they would have to eat a large portion of his salary.
He's due to make $18.5M next season and though it looks like he is starting to get back into his old form, many teams would not want to take that risk. They would probably have to eat $10M or even $15M of the last year on his contract to get back anything good in return.
Perez is interesting because on sure someone out there would be interested in a young left hander. But the problem is that he is really bad. If the Mets could eat $11M of the $12M remaining on the final year of his contract, like the Angels did with Gary Matthews Jr., then they would probably be able to find a suitor for him.
I think Castillo is a lost cause and not a lot of teams will want him. I say just eat the $6M remaining on his contract and release him.
The Mets will try to void Rodriguez's contract, but that doesn't look like it will happen. If they fight it hard enough I do think they'll be able to get something though. It looks like the won't have to pay the remaining $3M they owe him this season, but I find it unlikely they will be able to get out of the $11.5M they owe him in 2011 and the $3.5M buyout in 2012.
The Mets do have a lot of money coming off the book after the 2011 season. In just those four players (assuming they buyout Rodriguez's contract), they would have $44.5M in freed payroll. That leaves the Mets in a good position to go after Grady Sizemore, Mark Buehrle, and Jonathan Broxton. But now we're getting ahead of ourselves. The 2012 season is far away.
After the disappointments of the last four seasons, it's time to change the face of this team. Players that I would part with would be Beltran, Perez, Castillo, John Maine,and Jeff Francoeur. I also wouldn't resign Pedro Feliciano, Rod Barajas, Henry Blanco, and Fernando Tatis. I don't know if the list would stop there, but there are only a few players I wouldn't move. That list would be David Wright, Johan Santana, Jose Reyes, Ike Davis, Angel Pagan, Mike Pelfrey and Jon Niese.
The team in 2011 would be much younger, with more of an eye on the future. As far as free agents I would go hard after Cliff Lee and Orlando Hudson, but that would be it.
So in a my world this would be the line-up and rotation for the 2011 season:
Jose Reyes (SS) – Angel Pagan (CF) – David Wright (3B) – Ike Davis (1B) – Jason Bay (LF) – Orlando Hudson (2B) – Fernando Martinez (RF) – Josh Thole (C)
Johan Santana (LHP) – Cliff Lee (LHP) – Mike Pelfrey (RHP) – Jon Niese (LHP) – R.A. Dickey (RHP)
But what am I talking about 2011 for, the Mets still have a shot in 2010… right?

For those that didn't hear about Rob Dibble's comments during a Washington Nationals game, here is a transcript, courtesy of 